The BA’s High 50 Record Is a Portrait of Craft Brewing’s Id Disaster

TikTok has Fb terrified. Google is poisoning its personal search outcomes. Former longshot anti-woke Republican presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy simply purchased a stake in BuzzFeed. For those who wanted extra proof that Net 2.0’s dominant format for organizing info — the listing — was previous its prime, it’s actually began to stack up these days.

Nonetheless, there’s one listing that can endlessly stay related to our goal right here at Hop Take, reader: the Brewers Affiliation’s annual top-50 rating of craft breweries in america by quantity. The most recent version of this listing dropped in April 2024, however it wasn’t till final week, when the Could/June installment of the org’s New Brewer journal was printed, that brewery-by-brewery barrelage grew to become out there to the commerce press. These information, mixed with the listing itself and cross-referenced with broader consuming tendencies each inside the beer class and past it, give us a reasonably good, albeit incomplete, image of what’s occurring on the higher finish of the American craft brewing enterprise lately.

Within the not-so-grand custom of final decade’s digital discourse, I now current you with an inventory of my high 5 takeaways from this yr’s top-50 breweries listing. So as of rising significance…

5. The “may very well be worse” period was very literal final yr.

Final month on the BA’s 2024 Craft Brewers Convention, I reported on what I referred to as craft brewing’s “may very well be worse” period, a nod to a equally titled slide introduced on the occasion by BA chief economist Bart Watson. The premise is self-explanatory, and it’s borne out within the barrelage tables from 2023, which had 26 breweries within the BA-defined top-50 put up quantity declines, in comparison with 29 in 2022. (Seventeen of these declines have been single-digit percentages between 1 and eight %, as Brewbound’s Zoe Licata identified.) The section was up 1 % in combination year-over-year quantity in 2022; regardless of draft declines, extra off-premise competitors, and shifting drinker preferences, it was down 1 % in 2023. Might be worse, man.

4. The section remains to be top-heavy as hell, however there’s a slo-mo shakeup underway.

The vast majority of the nation’s ~10,000 breweries make lower than 1,000 barrels yearly, whereas the highest 10 producers put out a mean of 816,761 barrels, and a median of 472,513 barrels. It’s an excellent reminder that craft brewing is something however a monolith; the views of its volume-pushing elder statesmen (e.g. the always-quotable Jim Koch of No. 2 Boston Beer Co.) should at all times be understood in that context. Nos. 1–5 remained unchanged final yr, however there was some reshuffling within the backside half of the BA-defined high 10, and it’s revealing. Athletic Brewing Co. elbowed its method into the No. 10 slot with a colossal 51 % quantity achieve over 2022, to 258,445 barrels, showcasing the ability of that agency’s worth proposition, if not essentially the viability of standalone NA-specific beer manufacturers extra broadly (it’s the one one out of this yr’s 50.) Brooklyn Brewery climbed to No. 8 with a 20 % achieve to 331,645 barrels final yr, with most if not all of that new quantity reportedly coming from exports, underscoring the potential energy of overseas markets to offset home doldrums. Tilray Manufacturers (No. 6) moved up three spots, with 461,097 barrels final yr, however loads of that quantity was addition-by-acquisition; the year-over-year comparability in 2024 is the place rubber meets street. Rubber has met street for Monster Beverage Co. — née CANarchy Craft Brewery Collective — which slid a spot to No. 9 with round 325,000 barrels. (As a flavored malt beverage, the Beast Unleashed’s sturdy sophomore yr isn’t mirrored on this complete.)

3. It’s “fall behind, get left behind” for 30-something breweries within the high 50…

I get no thrill out of reporting that 2023’s 5 greatest quantity losers are all venerable first- and early second-generation craft breweries that appear to have misplaced a step or a number of these days. Minhas Brewing Co., was the outlier right here in additional methods than one: It was based in 1845, and took the most important hit, sinking to No. 29 with round 90,000 barrels (-44 %.) Summit Brewery, based 1986, was down 32 % in 2023 (No. 37, 70,502 barrels); Drake’s Brewing Co., based 1989, down 22 % (No. 49, 47,975 barrels); Rogue Ales & Spirits, 1988, -17 % (No. 44, 55,881 barrels); Misplaced Coast, 1990, -14 % (No. 42, 58,350 barrels.) And so forth. The median age of this cohort is 36 years previous. It’s robust on the market for breweries of a sure age — but when final yr is any indication, that age is so much youthful than I’ve beforehand argued. Talking of which…

2. However among the oldest canines within the section are nonetheless studying new tips.

I’m pondering particularly about BA-defined section chief Yuengling, which tore up 2023 with 2,790,000 barrels. The nation’s oldest still-operating brewery (based 1845) notched 17 % progress final yr, which additionally noticed it increase additional west, including Kansas, Missouri, and Oklahoma to an current 23-state footprint that has included Texas, the nation’s greatest beer market, as of 2021. To not be proven up, August Schell Brewing Co. posted a 13 % enhance, bringing it to No. 24 with 107,100 barrels some 163 years after its 1860 founding. Then there’s 1890 child Narragansett Brewing Co. at No. 23 — again from the jaws (ahem) of irrelevance circa Y2K, rolling out sensible collaborations, packages, and extensions, and rising 10 % to 109,635 barrels. Heritage manufacturers hanging on thriving, we like to see it of us.

1. Macrobrewer-owned manufacturers are principally middling — however sometimes distinctive.

Among the manufacturers excluded from the BA’s listing are making main, segment-advancing strikes on severe denominators. New Belgium Brewing, which exited the org after finishing its 2019 sale to the Kirin subsidiary Lion Little World Drinks, lately surpassed Molson Coors (which owns Blue Moon and a handful of different breweries) in NielsenIQ-tracked craft retail scans analyzed by Bump Williams Consulting to turn out to be the beyond-BA off-premise chief. You could not take into account Voodoo Ranger to be a craft beer, what with its cloying fruit flavors and c-store ubiquity, however it’s a standard-bearer for the section with a significant demographic, and it helped develop NBB’s quantity 12 % final yr, to 1,383,000 barrels. Anheuser-Busch InBev’s Kona model was up greater than 12 % in {dollars} year-to-date by way of April 2024, demonstrating the enduring energy of compelling way of life branding — and, let’s be actual, ABI’s wholesaler community. (Kona is a part of the Craft Brewers Alliance, which additionally contains Cisco Brewing, so it’s exhausting to say how a lot quantity it gained by itself.) It’s a blended bag for different acquired craft manufacturers, although. The rest of ABI’s craft portfolio is struggling. As soon as-proud Lagunitas is languishing below Heineken’s heavy company hand and calling it quits on Chicago, and aside from Bell’s Brewery (purchased by Lion Little World in 2021 and up 5 % quantity on the yr), all the opposite macro-acquired craft brewers have been down.

🤯 Hop-ocalypse Now

Nearly since medicine like Ozempic and Wegovy hit the mainstream in 2023, public-health officers and commerce varieties alike have contemplated the long-term results they could have on consuming habits, given customers’ reviews of decreased longing for alcohol whereas on the medication. Earlier this month, pharmaceutical big Novo Nordisk introduced plans to check that very aspect impact of its name-brand medicine — however with a give attention to liver well being (which is a profitable medical utility) moderately than habit (which can or is probably not.) Alcohol-abuse specialists are excited anyway, as a result of the sector is perennially underfunded, and novel remedies are in determined demand. Higher to have Large Pharma’s oblique consideration than none in any respect, in different phrases. What a system we’ve obtained, eh?

📈 Ups…

The Nationwide Beer Wholesalers Affiliation listed one other month of progress in Could, suggesting a robust summer season gross sales season to return… The American Cider Affiliation’s pommelier certification program has formally expanded to Europe… Molson Coors’ advertising crew simply gained an Effie Award, and with bullseyes like the Large Inexperienced Kegg, how may it not?… An administrative choose rejected the Kroger/Albertsons bid to withhold execs’ texts…

📉 …and downs

Molson Coors is “pulling a Stella Artois” with Peroni, shifting the Italian import’s manufacturing to the U.S. for stateside gross sales… After simply two years, California hard-kombucha maker JuneShine has closed its Brooklyn ‘booch outpost… Anheuser-Busch InBev’s spirits-based Bud Gentle Seltzer substitute, NÜTRL, issued poisonous tumblers which have poisoned 43 individuals in Canada, oof… The Home of Representatives authorised a Farm Invoice draft that will kibosh delta-8 THC seltzers… The Drug Enforcement Administration’s newest steering throws delta-9 THC merchandise’ future into extra jeopardy, too…

This story is part of VP Professional, our free platform and e-newsletter for drinks business professionals, masking wine, beer, liquor, and past. Join VP Professional now!